News

Rights of rejected asylum seekers at risk in EU return hub Rwanda agreement

The Danish Refugee Council (DRC) is concerned by the announcement by Denmark, Austria, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands that they intend to establish a joint return hub arrangement in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers from Europe.

While states have the right to return people who have no legal right to remain in Europe, transferring them to countries with which they have no connection and which have questionable track-records for protecting human rights carries a high risk of undermining human rights protections and accountability. States must uphold European and international human rights law and ensure fair, efficient and credible asylum procedures, alongside the need for prompt and humane return arrangements for those who do not have a legal right to remain in the five countries

Serious unanswered questions

While details of the announcement remain limited, participating governments have indicated that rejected asylum seekers could be transferred to Rwanda under a common European departure centre scheme in 2027. 

DRC strongly recommends the governments involved to clarify: 

  • Which rights they will have and how these will be protected in practice  

  • Who will be responsible if those rights are violated  

  • What independent monitoring and oversight mechanism will be established  

  • What long-term solutions will be available for those who cannot return to their countries of origin. 

If governments proceed with this model, DRC urges them to guarantee that people transferred to Rwanda have their rights protected and have access to the services needed to integrate into Rwandan society should they choose to stay. 

Costly, risky and unlikely to deter displacement

Evidence from similar externalisation arrangements suggests that such schemes can be highly expensive, legally complex and difficult to implement while safeguarding rights. 

There is also little evidence that restrictive migration policies deter people from seeking safety. Research released earlier this year by DRC’s Mixed Migration Centre found that restrictive migration politics have little impact on people’s decisions to migrate or seek protection in Europe but have serious consequences on human lives. DRC's experience globally likewise shows that people are primarily driven by conflict, persecution, insecurity and lack of opportunity, rather than by changes in migration policy.

A better approach

Rather than investing significant resources in legally complex externalisation schemes, DRC encourages European governments to strengthen existing asylum and return systems, expand access to independent return counselling and reintegration support, and increase investment in safe and legal pathways. 

Our experience shows that when people receive accurate information about their options, access to counselling, appropriate support and sufficient time to make informed decisions, voluntary return and sustainable reintegration outcomes are more likely. 

Any return policy must be grounded in respect for international law, human dignity and effective protection safeguards. These principles should remain at the centre of Europe's response to displacement and migration. 

DRC remains available to engage with decision makers on these complex issues to strengthen refugee protection, solidarity and international responsibility-sharing 

More content like this

News

DRC position: New proposal on return will make it difficult for rejected asylum seekers to return voluntarily, extending the use of force, sanctions, and detention

Europe EU +4
News

Joint statement: EU 'safe country' and return proposals would seriously undermine protection and human dignity

Europe EU +1
News

DRC recommendations on the reform of the EU return rules

Denmark EU +4
News

Pressemeddelelse: Nye flygtningetal viser, at vi har brug for mere international solidaritet

News

Pressemeddelelse: Kommentar om muligheden for at overføre asylansøgere og flygtninge til tredjelande

News

Statement on the Danish proposal to potentially externalize the asylum procedure

News

Joint Statement: NGOs call on Member States

News

Joint NGO Statement: The EU must not be complicit in the loss of lives at sea and in rights violations at Europe’s borders

Read more about ...

Climate Conflict El Niño Emergency Humanitarian mine action Occupied Palestinian territory Syria Ukraine Afghanistan Algeria Anticipatory action Asia Asylum Bangladesh Burkina Faso Cameroon Chad Children Civil society engagement Colombia Democratic Republic of Congo Denmark Diaspora Djibouti Drought East Africa Economic recovery Ethiopia EU Europe Health Innovation Iraq Jordan Kenya Latin America Lebanon Legal aid Libya Localization Mali Middle East Migration Myanmar Niger Nigeria Peace Promoting self-reliance Protection Return Safety and dignity Safety training Shelter Site Somalia South Sudan Sudan Tunisia Türkiye Uganda Venezuela WASH West & North Africa Women Yemen